tigblogs

Luciana Brasil - My Blog

Livros politicamente corretos não ajudam na educação

Translations available in: Portuguese (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | English | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

Politically correct books do not help in the education
Automatically translated into English thanks to WorldLingo
Cantiga “I shot the wood in the cat” in some schools passed to be sung as “I did not shoot the wood in the cat”, the “ox of the black face” as “ox of the Piauí”. The calls politically correct expressions had invaded our daily one. A doutorado thesis of, defended at the beginning of the month in the College of Education of the USP, analyzed the presence of politically correct in infantile books and cantigas and concluded that the presence of these expressions does not contribute for an improvement in the education of the children.

Ilan Brenman, responsible for the intitled research the conviction of Emília: a reflection on politically correct the book production destined to the children, is infantile book writer and accountant of histories. It was interested itself for the subject because he is affected in its daily professional, for professors and readers who complain of violent or inadequate considered thematic histories with to infancy: death, war, jealousy, anger etc.

In visits the schools of the Great São Paulo, Brenman noticed that the infantile traditional books are being substituted for publications that book flame in “good ways” and on “preconceptions”. In these cartilhas, it counts that histories turn around narratives on good ways and absence of preconception.

The researcher passed, then, to a historical book analysis in good ways and found a book of Erasmo de Roterdã, call pueril Civility (of séc. XVI), that it treats, in well similar terms, of the subjects that deal with books good ways for children. An example is the ways to the table: in the book of intent Erasmo it for inadequate forms of if holding, as to assoar the nose during the meal, not to drink liquids while it eats, to chew of closed mouth. In current books it has the same orientações. Brenman, however, observes is that it has 500 years when was written the book of Erasmo, this “label” was not common in the society. It considers then that the book had a paper in history, but today understands that he has not felt “to teach” good ways to the children by means of books, nor to give a “modern roupagem” to one cartilha exceeded.

In politically correct book histories, Brenman sees other problems. “These new books hide the conflict, they do not have no incorreção, and they impose a moral of it are for inside. We observe each time little witches, wolf-bad, little monsters ". It evaluates that this is bad for the education, therefore “does not advance to subestimarmos the children. All they have a sadist part, but of some form the child if projects in the witch of history, and thus she works with its aggressive side ". Still according to writer, the family finished passing its paper in the education of the child and the school, in turn, delegated its paper to books.

The conviction of Emília

Brenman evaluates that the last consequences of this monitoring on infantile stories, would be to condemn personages as the Emília, of Monteiro Lobato: “the Emília is famous for its revolt and its incorreções, and the favour of it is in this”. Taking the last consequences of the politically correct one in literature, the story ““Negrinho of the pasturing” would have that to pass if to call “Afrodescendentezinho the pasturing””. “One never published as many books and it never had as much violence in the schools”, standes out the researcher. According to it, this test that is not possible to establish relation between the two phenomena. Some infantile books, cantigas and the videogames if had transformed into “bodes expiatórios” of the violence in the schools, but it comes of multiple factors as: the desestruturação of the families, the lack of preparation of the professors, the excess of pupils in the classrooms, etc. In accordance with Ilan, the educators who make this relation say to prezar for the “peace in infantile stories, but this is the peace of the cemetaries”.

The study Tavares was guided by Hercília de Miranda, teacher pensioner of the College of Education of the USP.

Source: Agency USP of Notice

Tags:
You must be logged in to add tags.

Luciana Brasil's Profile

Luciana Brasil's Friends


Latest Posts


Uma em cada quatro...
Ipea: preço alto...
Mais de 90% querem...
Jovens com depressão...
Pastoral do Menor...

Monthly Archive


July 2008
August 2008
September 2008
October 2008
November 2008
December 2008
February 2009
May 2009
June 2009
July 2009
December 2009
June 2010
August 2010
October 2010
November 2010
December 2010

Change Language




Tags Archive


aids amazonia brasil ciencia cultura desemprego desenvolvimento direitoshumanos drogas educação eleições emprego ensino escolas genero jovens juventude meioambiente mulheres participação paz pobreza política proteção saúde sustentabilidade trabalho violencia voluntariado índios

Filter By Type


Travel
Topics

Friends
*ViCtoria
+pancho+
3ooo
@criticarbh
A Better Community for All (ABC4All)
a.st.l
Aarti Saluja
abbo
ABDALHADI ALIJLA
abdeslam ait abbouali
abdul-mumin
abo habiba
ADAM Q.R
Adel
ADEOLA
Adham Tobail
Adolfo BESE rocha
Adrielle Saldanha
Ahed Ali
ahmed
Alao Oyewole
Alejandro Chipana
Alenwi
alex
Alex Simon
ALI Mohammed Ali EID
Alive Arts Media / / Alive Magazine
Alpha Nicol
Alpha Vision Alliance
AmandaG.
Ambunga Bin Masoya Patrick
Amir Wasim
Amit अमित
Ana Laura Becker Aguiar
Anais Bertie
Anamaria Almeida
Anand Koti
andre
Andrea Arzaba
Andrés Romero
Andy Lorenzo
Annibal Machado
AnoharJohn
association dunenyo
Atta ur Rehman Qureashi
Atta-ur-Rehman
BaBaNe Kamal Titilayo
Bad_hyena
Belal jahjooh
Best Volunteer Organization Nepal
Bipin Pokhrel
Bips
Bruna Milani
Brunno Manfra
buburuza_03
Burgis Sethna
bxg
byron
Camila
Canada i love you
Carla Cristina Hirata Miyasaka
Carlos Eduardo Juvencio
Casey Hughlett
Centre For Rural Health & Development [CRHD]
cheerleader17
chelsea
Chester Anthony Elmore
Chiara C.
CHILD RESCUE MISSION CRM
clarita zarate
code
Conrad Rein
Conte
Coquille
cosmas amwayi
Cristina
Crystal Walters
Cynthia Ramos
Dada Oladele
Daiana Roberta S. Gomes
Daiane SC
Damian Profeta
Daniela
Danish Khan MCP, CompTIA A+ & CompTIA Network+ Certified Professional (webmaster@mdanishkhan.tk)
Dave Matthews
davyk
Denis Nyakach
Desgama
devan singaram
Dileep Paul
Diogo Andre
Dionísio Piauiense
Doghri Saber
DOUMBIA
Dr. Ahmed Tammam
DUKE
Efraim Neto
Elaine CrisXavante (Comitiva Esperança)
Elisabeth Cardoso Moniz
Elizabeth Arceo
Elvis O. Aigbogun
Emily Briggs
Emmanuel
emmanuel Enow
Endalkachew H/Michael
Ernesto Antonini
explorerpaul
Fazal
fireandice-nrms-mbrygider
firman kamil
flaviad
gabriel
Gary W. Horton
Gavin Bone
genel
George
German A. de la Espriella L.
GHJ
GREEN NETWORK FOR YOUTH SIERRA LEONE
Guilherme
Habeeb Ibrahim
Hafiidhaturrahmah
Haneen Snounu
Harrison Ferreira dos Santos
hasan zaman
hayadin
Hayk
hazem al jaber
hcbcommuni
Helen Borodina
Hendarmawan
Henning
i-exist.
Ibrahim Muhammed
idreeskhan
Idris victor
IEC Nepal
Igor Morais
Ikoli victor
ilyes
imran mazher
International network of missing chIldren and adults
Invisible Youth Network
Ionara Silva
irfan yaqoob
Ishwor Malla
issam
Ivens Reyner
jacqueline stein
James Baja
Jaqueline Soares
Jason Liester
Jay
JC Perú
Jessica
Jhon Esteban
Jiban Baral
Joana Chagas
João Malavolta
joe
Johanny Arilexis Pérez Sierra
john
John Adams
Joyce
Julia
Julia Nader Dietrich
Julie Amelia
Julio Alexander Parra
KeDee
Kelli Korducki
Kelly Culliney
Kelvin Uever
KidsRock4Kids
Kirsten
KOLAMAG
KOUYATE
Krishna Giri
Kughan
Lady Kathy Sittloh
Laurent Ye
lawrence edward
Liam O'Doherty
lobotzin
Lorena_x
Luana
Ludy Amano
Lymos
Majonagbe Adeolu
Malcolm Lawrence
Man of the Green Meadow
Mandaa *
Manuella Donato
Marcos Perez
Marilia Miller®
Mário Attab
Mauricio Donavan Rodrigues Paniza
maxwell Adeo Adew
Mayang Rizky
Meron
Miguel Covarrubias
Mohamed Barrie
Mohamed Eid
Mohamed Elkashash
Mohamed Sheriff Khanu
Mohammed Jahjouh
Monica Fink
MOSES EYINLA
mourad
Ms. Alisha
Muhammad Umar
MUIDEEN
Mümtaz Derya Tarhan
mustapha kraoua
MUWAYI IDDI
NABAKISHORE CHANDA
Nabil Chemli
navitha
Nepalese Teacher
nour halawani
Ogaga Onowighose
oshoke inaede
Otavio Mori
Pablo Esquivel
PAULO CESAR MARTINS
Paulo Farine
PEACE-SEEKER
Peta Masudi
Peter
positive awareness service society
Professor. Eugenio Roberto CALIGIURI
Quentin Fininen
Raisa Bhuiyan
Ramatis Radis
ramzi abu abdou
Raquel Lins
Ravin Singh
raymond addo akuffo
Reiner Mora
Renata Florentino
Richard Rodriguez Gaerste
Rodrigo P.
Rukh Gurung
Ryon C. Patterson
sadick
SAJI JUDE
Saladin Abuhamdieh
Salam alzubedi
Sam-Smart
Samuel B.S.R. Cruz
Santigie Bayo Dumbuya
Sara
Segun Oni
seyi
Shaninski Alivastra
Shashi Bikram Karki
shelbyyeager
Shreejana K.C
Simon James
spio-garbrah ebenezer
Stop Violence !
SUGNANARAO.VELPULA
Suneboy
Swapnil
Tala Nabulsi
talia delgado
Tanimara
Taylor
Tetteh Kofi Hadjor
Thando Sebesho - Moiloa
Thiago
Thiago Lucas.
thulani simelane
Timothy So
Tony Pent
Tony Samara
trojeanhilaire
tuncer
urama bertrand chijioke
Victor Ezlien-Taylor
Victor Reyes
VICTORY ASHAMOLE C
VISHNU
Vítor Massao
WalterTrejo
Wasukira Ambrose
wenxin
Williams Tadino
wsat
Xhaif
Yaisha S. Cordero
yann
Yashoda
Yassir EL OUARZADI
Yougee
Youth Fed
yusuf
Zach
Zainul (www.connecttask.com)
zidanye
Zohal
بييدا
محمد محمد جبلي
๑۩۞۩๑ brightEYES™๑۩۞۩๑


134580 views
Important Disclaimer